Oral Arguments - Thursday, November 30, 2023 | Appellate Division

Images and video recordings of the Court’s Justices on the Court’s website or otherwise may not be used to advance private interests or in furtherance of any commercial purpose (see Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics Op. 20-158; see generally 22 NYCRR 100.2 [C], 100.4 [D] [3]).

972
KA 22-01556

PEOPLE
V
SARAH M. KLINE

Criminal Possession Weapon

RYAN J. MULDOON	SUB
CHRISTOPHER T. VALDINA	SUB

973
KA 22-00343

PEOPLE
V
AARON LUCAS

Rape

NICHOLAS P. DIFONZO	SUB
MINDY F. VANLEUVAN	SUB

974
KA 20-01192

PEOPLE
V
CARLOS ORTEGA, JR.

Burglary

JANET C. SOMES	SUB
SCOTT MYLES	SUB

975
KA 20-00968

PEOPLE
V
JULIO RESTO

Attempted Criminal Possession Controlled Substance

BRAEDAN M. GILLMAN	SUB
PAUL G. LYONS	SUB

PLAY

976
KA 18-02137

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
ERICK O. FIGUEROA

Murder

JONATHAN FREDERIC GARVIN	10
NANCY GILLIGAN	10

977
KA 23-00571

PEOPLE
V
BRIAN R. BUSSOM

Sex Offender Registration Act

DAVID R. JUERGENS	SUB
NANCY GILLIGAN	SUB

PLAY

978
KA 19-02220

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
COREY CLINTON

Murder

PAUL SKIP LAISURE	15
MARTIN P. MCCARTHY, II	10

PLAY

979
KA 22-01360

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
NAQUAN SUMLER

Rape

BRADLEY E. KEEM	10
BRADLEY W. OASTLER	10

PLAY

980
KA 22-01196

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
JEFFREY R. HICKEY

Attempted Assault

BRADLEY E. KEEM	10
JOSHUA J. TONRA	10

PLAY

981
CAF 22-00559

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
ADAM M. C.

Terminate Parental Rights

CHARU NARANG	SUB
MARY M. WHITESIDE	10

PLAY

982
CAF 23-00117

PLAY

BRANDON P.
V
JENNIFER M. C.

Paternity

CAITLIN M. CONNELLY	5
MARY HOPE BENEDICT	5

PLAY

983
CAF 22-00797

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
KAMERON R.

Custody

ROBERT J. GALLAMORE	10
AMY LEIGH HALLENBECK	5
SCOTT A. OTIS	10

984
CAF 22-00798

IN THE MATTER OF
KAMERON C. R.

Order of Protection

TO BE ARGUED WITH #983

PLAY

985
CAF 22-01792

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
CLARISSA F.

Neglect

VERONICA L. REED	SUB
ALLISON B. CARROW	SUB
DAVID J. PAJAK	5
WILLIAM D. BRODERICK, JR.	10
MINDY LYNN MARRANCA	5

986
CA 22-01627

CHERYL STEPHENS
V
CITY OF BUFFALO

Default Judgment

SETTLED

987
CA 22-01888

CHERYL STEPHENS
V
CITY OF BUFFALO

Vacate Judgment

TO BE ARGUED WITH #986

PLAY

988
CA 22-01447

PLAY

BARBERRY COVE, LLC
V
TOWN OF HENRIETTA BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW

RPTL

PETER J. WEISHAAR	15
ROBERT L. JACOBSON	15

PLAY

989
CA 22-01667

PLAY

2006905 ONTARIO INC.
V
GOODRICH AEROSPACE CANADA, LTD

Contract

JOSEPH E. ZDARSKY	30
JOHN W. CERRETA II	30

PLAY

990
CA 22-01763

PLAY

GAYLE BUNN
V
FAXTON-ST. LUKE'S HEALTH CARE

Summary Judgment

ANTHONY ALEXANDER MURAD	15
ANDREW BORELLI	15
EVAN ROSSI	15

PLAY

991
CA 22-01746

PLAY

CHRISTOPHER SMITH
V
ANNA J. SMITH

Partition

JANET D. CALLAHAN	15
DANIEL J. PAUTZ	15

PLAY

992
CA 22-01747

PLAY

CHRISTOPHER SMITH
V
ANNA J. SMITH

Partition

PLAY

993
CA 23-00858

PLAY

CHRISTOPHER SMITH
V
ANNE J. SMITH

Partition

PLAY

994
CA 23-01008

PLAY

CHRISTOPHER SMITH
V
ANNE J. SMITH

Partition

PLAY

995
CA 22-01342

PLAY

STACIE COMBS
V
JULIE A. MADEJSKI, M.D.

Summary Judgment

KATHLEEN M. SWEET	10
THERESA M. WALSH	15
HEDWIG M. AULETTA	15
JENNA W. KLUCSIK	5

PLAY

996
CA 23-00886

PLAY

65 LAKE AVENUE, LLC
V
LENDER CONSULTING SERVICES, INC.

Dismiss Complaint

STEVEN W. WILLIAMS	15
RICHARD ALAN MOORE	15

RULES FILING FORMS ASSIGNED COUNSEL MOTIONS PERFECTING APPEALS ARGUMENTS DECISIONS NOTICES

ACCESSIBILITY

If you are unable to access the archive of a particular argument because of a disability, please contact Alan Ross, Deputy Clerk of the Court and the Court’s designated ADA Liaison (by e-mail at aross@nycourts.gov or by telephone at 585-530-3102), to request a reasonable accommodation.

Hearing Assistance

ASSISTED LISTENING devices are available in each courtroom during arguments. Please see a court attendant when you enter the courtroom.

CLOSED CAPTIONING is available while viewing archived (not live) oral arguments. Hover your mouse over the video and click the [cc] icon to activate the captions. Please note: these captions are generated by a computer algorithm and are not considered a transcript of the proceedings.

PRIVACY NOTICE

To protect the privacy interests of individuals in matters before the Court, and the need to protect litigants, particularly children, from harm, those persons appearing for oral argument may not disclose:

an individual's social-security number or taxpayer-identification number;
date of an individual's birth;
name of an individual known to be a minor;
or a financial-account number.

Any person responsible for such disclosure at oral argument must report such disclosure to the receptionist immediately following their argument before the Court.

Periodically the court may suspend a broadcast to protect the privacy interests of individuals in matters before the Court.

Thu Nov 30 ArgumentsHon. Samuel L. Green Courtroom

972 KA 22-01556

PEOPLE VSARAH M. KLINE

973 KA 22-00343

PEOPLE VAARON LUCAS

974 KA 20-01192

PEOPLE VCARLOS ORTEGA, JR.

975 KA 20-00968

PEOPLE VJULIO RESTO

976 KA 18-02137

PEOPLE VERICK O. FIGUEROA

977 KA 23-00571

PEOPLE VBRIAN R. BUSSOM

978 KA 19-02220

PEOPLE VCOREY CLINTON

979 KA 22-01360

PEOPLE VNAQUAN SUMLER

980 KA 22-01196

PEOPLE VJEFFREY R. HICKEY

981 CAF 22-00559

IN THE MATTER OFADAM M. C.

982 CAF 23-00117

BRANDON P. VJENNIFER M. C.

983 CAF 22-00797

IN THE MATTER OFKAMERON R.

984 CAF 22-00798

IN THE MATTER OFKAMERON C. R.

TO BE ARGUED WITH #983

985 CAF 22-01792

IN THE MATTER OFCLARISSA F.

986 CA 22-01627

CHERYL STEPHENS VCITY OF BUFFALO

SETTLED

987 CA 22-01888

CHERYL STEPHENS VCITY OF BUFFALO

TO BE ARGUED WITH #986

988 CA 22-01447

BARBERRY COVE, LLC VTOWN OF HENRIETTA BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW

989 CA 22-01667

2006905 ONTARIO INC. VGOODRICH AEROSPACE CANADA, LTD

990 CA 22-01763

GAYLE BUNN VFAXTON-ST. LUKE'S HEALTH CARE

991 CA 22-01746

CHRISTOPHER SMITH VANNA J. SMITH

992 CA 22-01747

CHRISTOPHER SMITH VANNA J. SMITH

993 CA 23-00858

CHRISTOPHER SMITH VANNE J. SMITH

994 CA 23-01008

CHRISTOPHER SMITH VANNE J. SMITH

995 CA 22-01342

STACIE COMBS VJULIE A. MADEJSKI, M.D.

996 CA 23-00886

65 LAKE AVENUE, LLC VLENDER CONSULTING SERVICES, INC.

ACCESSIBILITY

Hearing Assistance

PRIVACY NOTICE

Comment Share your thoughts, comments or suggestions as part of the Court's Excellence Initiative.

Justices of the Court

Clerk of the Court

Programs and Services

The Fourth Department

Attorney Matters

M. Dolores DenmanCourthouse

Appeals & Original Proceedings

Thu Nov 30 Arguments
Hon. Samuel L. Green Courtroom

972
KA 22-01556

PEOPLE
V
SARAH M. KLINE

973
KA 22-00343

PEOPLE
V
AARON LUCAS

974
KA 20-01192

PEOPLE
V
CARLOS ORTEGA, JR.

975
KA 20-00968

PEOPLE
V
JULIO RESTO

976
KA 18-02137

PEOPLE
V
ERICK O. FIGUEROA

977
KA 23-00571

PEOPLE
V
BRIAN R. BUSSOM

978
KA 19-02220

PEOPLE
V
COREY CLINTON

979
KA 22-01360

PEOPLE
V
NAQUAN SUMLER

980
KA 22-01196

PEOPLE
V
JEFFREY R. HICKEY

981
CAF 22-00559

IN THE MATTER OF
ADAM M. C.

982
CAF 23-00117

BRANDON P.
V
JENNIFER M. C.

983
CAF 22-00797

IN THE MATTER OF
KAMERON R.

984
CAF 22-00798

IN THE MATTER OF
KAMERON C. R.

985
CAF 22-01792

IN THE MATTER OF
CLARISSA F.

986
CA 22-01627

CHERYL STEPHENS
V
CITY OF BUFFALO

987
CA 22-01888

CHERYL STEPHENS
V
CITY OF BUFFALO

988
CA 22-01447

BARBERRY COVE, LLC
V
TOWN OF HENRIETTA BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW

989
CA 22-01667

2006905 ONTARIO INC.
V
GOODRICH AEROSPACE CANADA, LTD

990
CA 22-01763

GAYLE BUNN
V
FAXTON-ST. LUKE'S HEALTH CARE

991
CA 22-01746

CHRISTOPHER SMITH
V
ANNA J. SMITH

992
CA 22-01747

CHRISTOPHER SMITH
V
ANNA J. SMITH

993
CA 23-00858

CHRISTOPHER SMITH
V
ANNE J. SMITH

994
CA 23-01008

CHRISTOPHER SMITH
V
ANNE J. SMITH

995
CA 22-01342

STACIE COMBS
V
JULIE A. MADEJSKI, M.D.

996
CA 23-00886

65 LAKE AVENUE, LLC
V
LENDER CONSULTING SERVICES, INC.

M. Dolores Denman
Courthouse