Oral Arguments - Thursday, January 16, 2025 | Appellate Division

Images and video recordings of the Court’s Justices on the Court’s website or otherwise may not be used to advance private interests or in furtherance of any commercial purpose (see Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics Op. 20-158; see generally 22 NYCRR 100.2 [C], 100.4 [D] [3]).

PLAY

91
KA 23-02104

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
MICHAEL ROSS

CPL art 440

PARKER MACKAY	10
HARMONY A. HEALY	10

92
KA 16-01444

PEOPLE
V
STEVE FULCOTT

Criminal Possession Marihuana

STEVEN A. FELDMAN	SUB
AMY WALENDZIAK	SUB

PLAY

93
KA 22-00622

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
BENZINO E. REED

Manslaughter

JAMES A. HOBBS	5
RYAN ASHE	5

94
KA 22-01938

PEOPLE
V
JAKWAN CURRY

Criminal Possession Weapon

DREW R. DUBRIN	SUB
MARTIN P. MCCARTHY, II	SUB

95
KA 23-02054

PEOPLE
V
JAKWAN CURRY

Criminal Possession Weapon

TO BE ARGUED WITH #94

PLAY

96
KA 23-01726

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
JASON PERRY

Offering False Instrument Filing

DAVID R. JUERGENS	10
RYAN PAUL ASHE	10

PLAY

97
KA 21-01564

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
DERRICK C. MARSH

Assault

BHAGYASHREE GUPTE	15
LORI PETTIT RIEMAN	15

PLAY

98
KA 20-01680

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
MARLANDO A. ALLEN

Murder

FABIENNE NOELLE SANTACROCE	5
LISA GRAY	10

PLAY

99
KA 23-01490

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
SHAWN WRIGHT

Criminal Possession Weapon

BRADLEY E. KEEM	10
DAVID DE LA GARZA BASSETT	10

PLAY

100
CAF 23-01642

PLAY

ERICA NICOLE SMITH
V
BENJAMIN V. BUTLER

Custody

PARKER MACKAY	10
MICHAEL JAMES CAPUTO	5

PLAY

101
CAF 22-02012

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
MALIAH B.

Neglect

CHARLES J. GREENBERG	SUB
JULIE VILJOEN	10
ROXANNA QUINN HERREID	5

PLAY

102
CAF 22-02013

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
MODESTY B.

Neglect

TO BE ARGUED WITH #101

PLAY

103
CAF 22-02015

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
MCKELL K.

Neglect

TO BE ARGUED WITH #101

PLAY

104
CAF 23-01437

PLAY

TREVOR TORRES
V
KATRINA A. PFEIFFER

Custody

ERIC FERRANTE	15
REBECCA L. KONST	15
SCOTT A. OTIS	10

PLAY

105
CA 23-01580

PLAY

PB-57 DOE
V
THE LUTHERAN CHURCH MISSOURI SYNOD

Summary Judgment

OVER THE TERM

PLAY

105.1
CA 23-01581

PLAY

PB-57 DOE
V
THE LUTHERAN CHURCH MISSOURI SYNOD

Summary Judgment

OVER THE TERM

PLAY

106
CA 23-01438

PLAY

KENNETH BAKER
V
STATE OF NEW YORK

Negligence

MICHAEL E. DALEY	15
OWEN DEMUTH	10

107
TP 24-01265

CITY OF ROCHESTER
V
REMINGTON REYES

CPLR art 78 Proceeding Transferred by Order of

CHRISTOPHER S. NOONE	SUB
DANIEL DEBOLT	SUB

108
CA 24-00237

PETER R. MORGAN
V
CITY OF UTICA

Summary Judgment

ZACHARY C. OREN

SUB

PLAY

109
CA 23-01826

PLAY

JACEK WOLOSZUK
V
WENDE LOGAN-YOUNG, M.D.

Vacate Dismissal

EDWARD J. MARKARIAN	15
MARGARET E. SOMERSET	15
BARBARA D. GOLDBERG	15

PLAY

110
CA 23-01879

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
WENDY COOPER (ROSWELL PARK COMPREHENSIVE CANCER CTR)

Arbitration

MICHAEL EDWARD HICKEY	15
JENIFER MARCELLE WHARTON	15

PLAY

111
CA 23-01834

PLAY

DONALD J. LEONE
V
ELMWOOD BIDWELL REDEVELOPMENT COMPANY, LLC

Dismiss Complaint

JOHN A. COLLINS	15
JENNIFER PERSICO	15

112
CA 24-00050

AARON CHANG
V
BILLIE J. COLLINS-WELLS

Guardianship

SUSAN L. SCHNEIDER

SUB

PLAY

113
CA 23-02030

PLAY

BUFFALO NAVAL PARK COMMITTEE, INC.
V
WATER QUALITY INSURANCE SYNDICATE

Dismiss Complaint

JOHN T. KOLAGA	15
JOHN MAYNARD WOODS	15

RULES FILING FORMS ASSIGNED COUNSEL MOTIONS PERFECTING APPEALS ARGUMENTS DECISIONS NOTICES

ACCESSIBILITY

If you are unable to access the archive of a particular argument because of a disability, please contact Alan Ross, Deputy Clerk of the Court and the Court’s designated ADA Liaison (by e-mail at aross@nycourts.gov or by telephone at 585-530-3102), to request a reasonable accommodation.

Hearing Assistance

ASSISTED LISTENING devices are available in each courtroom during arguments. Please see a court attendant when you enter the courtroom.

CLOSED CAPTIONING is available while viewing archived (not live) oral arguments. Hover your mouse over the video and click the [cc] icon to activate the captions. Please note: these captions are generated by a computer algorithm and are not considered a transcript of the proceedings.

PRIVACY NOTICE

To protect the privacy interests of individuals in matters before the Court, and the need to protect litigants, particularly children, from harm, those persons appearing for oral argument may not disclose:

an individual's social-security number or taxpayer-identification number;
date of an individual's birth;
name of an individual known to be a minor;
or a financial-account number.

Any person responsible for such disclosure at oral argument must report such disclosure to the receptionist immediately following their argument before the Court.

Periodically the court may suspend a broadcast to protect the privacy interests of individuals in matters before the Court.

Thu Jan 16 ArgumentsHon. Samuel L. Green Courtroom

91 KA 23-02104

PEOPLE VMICHAEL ROSS

92 KA 16-01444

PEOPLE VSTEVE FULCOTT

93 KA 22-00622

PEOPLE VBENZINO E. REED

94 KA 22-01938

PEOPLE VJAKWAN CURRY

95 KA 23-02054

PEOPLE VJAKWAN CURRY

TO BE ARGUED WITH #94

96 KA 23-01726

PEOPLE VJASON PERRY

97 KA 21-01564

PEOPLE VDERRICK C. MARSH

98 KA 20-01680

PEOPLE VMARLANDO A. ALLEN

99 KA 23-01490

PEOPLE VSHAWN WRIGHT

100 CAF 23-01642

ERICA NICOLE SMITH VBENJAMIN V. BUTLER

101 CAF 22-02012

IN THE MATTER OFMALIAH B.

102 CAF 22-02013

IN THE MATTER OFMODESTY B.

TO BE ARGUED WITH #101

103 CAF 22-02015

IN THE MATTER OFMCKELL K.

TO BE ARGUED WITH #101

104 CAF 23-01437

TREVOR TORRES VKATRINA A. PFEIFFER

105 CA 23-01580

PB-57 DOE VTHE LUTHERAN CHURCH MISSOURI SYNOD

OVER THE TERM

105.1 CA 23-01581

PB-57 DOE VTHE LUTHERAN CHURCH MISSOURI SYNOD

OVER THE TERM

106 CA 23-01438

KENNETH BAKER VSTATE OF NEW YORK

107 TP 24-01265

CITY OF ROCHESTER VREMINGTON REYES

108 CA 24-00237

PETER R. MORGAN VCITY OF UTICA

109 CA 23-01826

JACEK WOLOSZUK VWENDE LOGAN-YOUNG, M.D.

110 CA 23-01879

IN THE MATTER OFWENDY COOPER (ROSWELL PARK COMPREHENSIVE CANCER CTR)

111 CA 23-01834

DONALD J. LEONE VELMWOOD BIDWELL REDEVELOPMENT COMPANY, LLC

112 CA 24-00050

AARON CHANG VBILLIE J. COLLINS-WELLS

113 CA 23-02030

BUFFALO NAVAL PARK COMMITTEE, INC. VWATER QUALITY INSURANCE SYNDICATE

ACCESSIBILITY

Hearing Assistance

PRIVACY NOTICE

Comment Share your thoughts, comments or suggestions as part of the Court's Excellence Initiative.

Justices of the Court

Clerk of the Court

Programs and Services

The Fourth Department

Attorney Matters

M. Dolores DenmanCourthouse

Appeals & Original Proceedings

Thu Jan 16 Arguments
Hon. Samuel L. Green Courtroom

91
KA 23-02104

PEOPLE
V
MICHAEL ROSS

92
KA 16-01444

PEOPLE
V
STEVE FULCOTT

93
KA 22-00622

PEOPLE
V
BENZINO E. REED

94
KA 22-01938

PEOPLE
V
JAKWAN CURRY

95
KA 23-02054

PEOPLE
V
JAKWAN CURRY

96
KA 23-01726

PEOPLE
V
JASON PERRY

97
KA 21-01564

PEOPLE
V
DERRICK C. MARSH

98
KA 20-01680

PEOPLE
V
MARLANDO A. ALLEN

99
KA 23-01490

PEOPLE
V
SHAWN WRIGHT

100
CAF 23-01642

ERICA NICOLE SMITH
V
BENJAMIN V. BUTLER

101
CAF 22-02012

IN THE MATTER OF
MALIAH B.

102
CAF 22-02013

IN THE MATTER OF
MODESTY B.

103
CAF 22-02015

IN THE MATTER OF
MCKELL K.

104
CAF 23-01437

TREVOR TORRES
V
KATRINA A. PFEIFFER

105
CA 23-01580

PB-57 DOE
V
THE LUTHERAN CHURCH MISSOURI SYNOD

105.1
CA 23-01581

PB-57 DOE
V
THE LUTHERAN CHURCH MISSOURI SYNOD

106
CA 23-01438

KENNETH BAKER
V
STATE OF NEW YORK

107
TP 24-01265

CITY OF ROCHESTER
V
REMINGTON REYES

108
CA 24-00237

PETER R. MORGAN
V
CITY OF UTICA

109
CA 23-01826

JACEK WOLOSZUK
V
WENDE LOGAN-YOUNG, M.D.

110
CA 23-01879

IN THE MATTER OF
WENDY COOPER (ROSWELL PARK COMPREHENSIVE CANCER CTR)

111
CA 23-01834

DONALD J. LEONE
V
ELMWOOD BIDWELL REDEVELOPMENT COMPANY, LLC

112
CA 24-00050

AARON CHANG
V
BILLIE J. COLLINS-WELLS

113
CA 23-02030

BUFFALO NAVAL PARK COMMITTEE, INC.
V
WATER QUALITY INSURANCE SYNDICATE

M. Dolores Denman
Courthouse