Oral Arguments - Tuesday, January 14, 2025 | Appellate Division

Images and video recordings of the Court’s Justices on the Court’s website or otherwise may not be used to advance private interests or in furtherance of any commercial purpose (see Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics Op. 20-158; see generally 22 NYCRR 100.2 [C], 100.4 [D] [3]).

PLAY

21
KA 22-00016

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
HEZEKIAH N. BURCH

Attempted Rape

ALINA YOUNG	10
ABIGAIL DOROTHY WHIPPLE	0
WILLIAM G. ZICKL	10

22
KA 24-00099

PEOPLE
V
BRANDON K. MCNEAL

Sex Offender Registration Act

CLEA WEISS	SUB
MARTIN P. MCCARTHY, II	SUB

PLAY

23
KA 24-00964

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
SPENCER MANGANIELLO

Possessing an Obscene Sexual Performance By a Chil

SHAUN M. CHASE	15
AMY LEIGH HALLENBECK	10

24
KA 10-01112

PEOPLE
V
KEVIN HARVEY

Murder

STEPHANIE M. STARE	SUB
LISA GRAY	SUB

PLAY

25
KA 23-00691

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
BRIAN THOMAS

Sexual Abuse

PHILIP ROTHSCHILD	SUB
ELISABETH DANNAN	10

26
KA 22-00125

PEOPLE
V
VAUGHN SANDERS

Attempted Murder

CASEY SCOTT DUFFY	SUB
ELISABETH DANNAN	SUB

PLAY

27
KA 20-01570

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
INDALECCIO RODRIGUEZ

Attempted Murder

ALLISON VIOLET MCMAHON	10
MINDY F. VANLEUVAN	10

PLAY

28
CAF 23-01683

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
LILLIANA S.

Neglect

VERONICA L. REED	SUB
SANDRA JOAN PACKARD	SUB
GARY MULDOON	5
SUSAN GRAY	5

PLAY

29
CAF 24-00261

PLAY

CINDY L. LACHENAUER
V
LAURA M. LACHENAUER-MYERS

Custody

SCOTT A. OTIS	10
MICHAEL STEINBERG	10
STEPHANIE N. DAVIS	5

30
CAF 23-01395

IN THE MATTER OF
MAXINE L.

Neglect

PETER J. DIGIORGIO, JR.	SUB
MARYANGELA SCALZO	SUB

PLAY

31
CAF 23-01708

PLAY

JOYCE KENYON
V
MOLLY NICOLETTA

Custody

LYLE T. HAJDU	SUB
DEBORAH K. JESSEY	5

PLAY

32
CA 24-00220

PLAY

FRANCISCO R.
V
STATE OF NEW YORK

Mental Hygiene Law

NATHANIEL V. RILEY	10
BRIAN MURAY LUSIGNAN	10

PLAY

33
CA 23-01908

PLAY

PETER DEMARCO
V
DOMINICK SEVERANCE

Dismiss Complaint

KEVIN J. FEDERATION	SUB
MICHAEL STEVEN STEINBERG	10

PLAY

34
CA 24-00002

PLAY

MARGARET P. BAUMAN
V
DENNIS R. BAUMAN

Summary Judgment

STEVEN BRIGGS SALCEDO	15
BARRY J. DONOHUE	15
ROBERT ROSS RADEL	SUB

PLAY

35
CA 24-00698

PLAY

MARGARET P. BAUMAN
V
DENNIS R. BAUMAN

Summary Judgment

TO BE ARGUED WITH #34

PLAY

36
CA 24-00699

PLAY

MARGARET P. BAUMAN
V
DENNIS R. BAUMAN

Summary Judgment

TO BE ARGUED WITH #34

PLAY

37
CA 24-00704

PLAY

MARGARET P. BAUMAN
V
DENNIS R. BAUMAN

Contract

TO BE ARGUED WITH #34

PLAY

38
CA 24-01165

PLAY

DAKOTA PREVOST
V
ASSOCIATED MATERIALS, LLC

Summary Judgment

HEIDI M.P. HYSELL	15
JAMES J. GASCON	15

PLAY

39
CA 24-01166

PLAY

DAKOTA PREVOST
V
ASSOCIATED MATERIALS, LLC

Summary Judgment

TO BE ARGUED WITH #38

PLAY

40
CA 23-02108

PLAY

DAVID BARKER
V
ANTHONY V. GERVERA

Summary Judgment

MICHAEL JON LONGSTREET	15
MATTHEW W. O'NEIL	15

PLAY

41
CA 24-00741

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
THE ESTATE OF JOHN R. SCHANOR, JR.

Probate

DIANE R. TIVERON	15
JEFFREY F. VOELKL	15

PLAY

42
CA 23-01366

PLAY

DENEB PIRRONE
V
SERVOTRONICS, INC.

Compel Discovery

ALYSHA M. NAIK	15
ANDREW DEBBINS	15

PLAY

43
CA 24-00114

PLAY

PATRICK RIMAR
V
COUNTRY CLUB OF BUFFALO

Dismiss Complaint

BRENDAN H. LITTLE	15
ROBERT ANTHONY FIORDALISO	SUB

PLAY

44
CA 24-00805

PLAY

NICHOLAS R. HAZLETT
V
MATTHEW D. NIEZGODA

Summary Judgment

RICHARD GREGORY MONACO	15
JAMES H. COSGRIFF, III	10

RULES FILING FORMS ASSIGNED COUNSEL MOTIONS PERFECTING APPEALS ARGUMENTS DECISIONS NOTICES

ACCESSIBILITY

If you are unable to access the archive of a particular argument because of a disability, please contact Alan Ross, Deputy Clerk of the Court and the Court’s designated ADA Liaison (by e-mail at aross@nycourts.gov or by telephone at 585-530-3102), to request a reasonable accommodation.

Hearing Assistance

ASSISTED LISTENING devices are available in each courtroom during arguments. Please see a court attendant when you enter the courtroom.

CLOSED CAPTIONING is available while viewing archived (not live) oral arguments. Hover your mouse over the video and click the [cc] icon to activate the captions. Please note: these captions are generated by a computer algorithm and are not considered a transcript of the proceedings.

PRIVACY NOTICE

To protect the privacy interests of individuals in matters before the Court, and the need to protect litigants, particularly children, from harm, those persons appearing for oral argument may not disclose:

an individual's social-security number or taxpayer-identification number;
date of an individual's birth;
name of an individual known to be a minor;
or a financial-account number.

Any person responsible for such disclosure at oral argument must report such disclosure to the receptionist immediately following their argument before the Court.

Periodically the court may suspend a broadcast to protect the privacy interests of individuals in matters before the Court.

Tue Jan 14 ArgumentsHon. Samuel L. Green Courtroom

21 KA 22-00016

PEOPLE VHEZEKIAH N. BURCH

22 KA 24-00099

PEOPLE VBRANDON K. MCNEAL

23 KA 24-00964

PEOPLE VSPENCER MANGANIELLO

24 KA 10-01112

PEOPLE VKEVIN HARVEY

25 KA 23-00691

PEOPLE VBRIAN THOMAS

26 KA 22-00125

PEOPLE VVAUGHN SANDERS

27 KA 20-01570

PEOPLE VINDALECCIO RODRIGUEZ

28 CAF 23-01683

IN THE MATTER OFLILLIANA S.

29 CAF 24-00261

CINDY L. LACHENAUER VLAURA M. LACHENAUER-MYERS

30 CAF 23-01395

IN THE MATTER OFMAXINE L.

31 CAF 23-01708

JOYCE KENYON VMOLLY NICOLETTA

32 CA 24-00220

FRANCISCO R. VSTATE OF NEW YORK

33 CA 23-01908

PETER DEMARCO VDOMINICK SEVERANCE

34 CA 24-00002

MARGARET P. BAUMAN VDENNIS R. BAUMAN

35 CA 24-00698

MARGARET P. BAUMAN VDENNIS R. BAUMAN

TO BE ARGUED WITH #34

36 CA 24-00699

MARGARET P. BAUMAN VDENNIS R. BAUMAN

TO BE ARGUED WITH #34

37 CA 24-00704

MARGARET P. BAUMAN VDENNIS R. BAUMAN

TO BE ARGUED WITH #34

38 CA 24-01165

DAKOTA PREVOST VASSOCIATED MATERIALS, LLC

39 CA 24-01166

DAKOTA PREVOST VASSOCIATED MATERIALS, LLC

TO BE ARGUED WITH #38

40 CA 23-02108

DAVID BARKER VANTHONY V. GERVERA

41 CA 24-00741

IN THE MATTER OFTHE ESTATE OF JOHN R. SCHANOR, JR.

42 CA 23-01366

DENEB PIRRONE VSERVOTRONICS, INC.

43 CA 24-00114

PATRICK RIMAR VCOUNTRY CLUB OF BUFFALO

44 CA 24-00805

NICHOLAS R. HAZLETT VMATTHEW D. NIEZGODA

ACCESSIBILITY

Hearing Assistance

PRIVACY NOTICE

Comment Share your thoughts, comments or suggestions as part of the Court's Excellence Initiative.

Justices of the Court

Clerk of the Court

Programs and Services

The Fourth Department

Attorney Matters

M. Dolores DenmanCourthouse

Appeals & Original Proceedings

Tue Jan 14 Arguments
Hon. Samuel L. Green Courtroom

21
KA 22-00016

PEOPLE
V
HEZEKIAH N. BURCH

22
KA 24-00099

PEOPLE
V
BRANDON K. MCNEAL

23
KA 24-00964

PEOPLE
V
SPENCER MANGANIELLO

24
KA 10-01112

PEOPLE
V
KEVIN HARVEY

25
KA 23-00691

PEOPLE
V
BRIAN THOMAS

26
KA 22-00125

PEOPLE
V
VAUGHN SANDERS

27
KA 20-01570

PEOPLE
V
INDALECCIO RODRIGUEZ

28
CAF 23-01683

IN THE MATTER OF
LILLIANA S.

29
CAF 24-00261

CINDY L. LACHENAUER
V
LAURA M. LACHENAUER-MYERS

30
CAF 23-01395

IN THE MATTER OF
MAXINE L.

31
CAF 23-01708

JOYCE KENYON
V
MOLLY NICOLETTA

32
CA 24-00220

FRANCISCO R.
V
STATE OF NEW YORK

33
CA 23-01908

PETER DEMARCO
V
DOMINICK SEVERANCE

34
CA 24-00002

MARGARET P. BAUMAN
V
DENNIS R. BAUMAN

35
CA 24-00698

MARGARET P. BAUMAN
V
DENNIS R. BAUMAN

36
CA 24-00699

MARGARET P. BAUMAN
V
DENNIS R. BAUMAN

37
CA 24-00704

MARGARET P. BAUMAN
V
DENNIS R. BAUMAN

38
CA 24-01165

DAKOTA PREVOST
V
ASSOCIATED MATERIALS, LLC

39
CA 24-01166

DAKOTA PREVOST
V
ASSOCIATED MATERIALS, LLC

40
CA 23-02108

DAVID BARKER
V
ANTHONY V. GERVERA

41
CA 24-00741

IN THE MATTER OF
THE ESTATE OF JOHN R. SCHANOR, JR.

42
CA 23-01366

DENEB PIRRONE
V
SERVOTRONICS, INC.

43
CA 24-00114

PATRICK RIMAR
V
COUNTRY CLUB OF BUFFALO

44
CA 24-00805

NICHOLAS R. HAZLETT
V
MATTHEW D. NIEZGODA

M. Dolores Denman
Courthouse