1. Home
  2. Term
  3. Calendar
February Term

Thu Feb 17 Argument #214

CA 21-00451

WILLIAM MCGIRR
    V
ROBIN SHIFFLET

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Erie County (Mark A. Montour, J.), entered March 25, 2021. The order granted the motion of defendant for summary judgment, denied the cross motion of plaintiff for summary judgment and dismissed the complaint. Plaintiff rented a cottage in Irving from defendant. On July 27, 2018, plaintiff sustained personal injury when the deck on which he was sitting collapsed. Supreme Court found that defendant established a lack of notice of a dangerous condition and that she did not create the condition, and that plaintiff failed to raise an issue of fact.

Images and video recordings of the Court’s Justices on the Court’s website or otherwise may not be used to advance private interests or in furtherance of any commercial purpose (see Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics Op. 20-158; see generally 22 NYCRR 100.2 [C], 100.4 [D] [3]).

196
KA 19-01856

PEOPLE
    V
JOSHUA STEWART

Sex Offender Registration Act

     DAVID R. JUERGENS SUB
     NANCY GILLIGAN SUB

197
KA 20-01368

PEOPLE
    V
JOSEPH HICKS

Sex Offender Registration Act

     DAVID R. JUERGENS SUB
     NANCY GILLIGAN SUB

198
KA 21-01076

PEOPLE
    V
MICHAEL JACKSON

Sex Offender Registration Act

     FRANCIS CIARDI SUB

199
KA 17-01337

PEOPLE
    V
ANDREW DOUGLAS, JR.

Criminal Possession Weapon

     HELEN SYME SUB
  DEREK HARNSBERGER SUB

200
KA 17-01373

PEOPLE
    V
MONTIEZ WEEMS

Burglary

     CAROLYN ROSE WALTHER SUB
     SCOTT MYLES SUB

201
KA 17-02131

PEOPLE
    V
KEYONI ADAMS

Arson

     DAVID R. JUERGENS SUB
     NANCY GILLIGAN SUB

202
KA 18-01853

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
HANZA MUHAMMAD

Murder

  PAUL J. CONNOLLY 10
  KENNETH H. TYLER, JR. 10

203
KA 19-01959

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
MICHAEL HURST

Rape

  KATHRYN B. FRIEDMAN 5
  ASHLEY R. LOWRY 5

204
KA 20-01305

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
JONATHAN R. PITTS

Robbery

  THOMAS MANNING LEITH 5
  KAITLYN M. GUPTILL 10

205
KA 18-00876

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
DARRYL GOODWIN

Criminal Possession Controlled Substance

  MARY M. WHITESIDE 10
  DEREK HARNSBERGER 10

206
CA 21-00512

PLAY

ROGER DUTTON
    V
YOUNG MEN'S CHRISTIAN ASSOCIATION

Dismiss Complaint

  BRENDA A. HARKAVAY 10
  RYAN A. LEMA 15

207
CA 21-00533

PLAY

KIM EHLENFIELD
    V
JASON W. KINGSBURY

Summary Judgment

  JOSHUA E. DUBS 15
  VANESSA ELLIOTT 15

208
CA 21-00621

PLAY

ALEXIS GONZALEZ
    V
RICHARD L. MCCARVER

Summary Judgment

  JOHN T. RYAN 15
  JESSICA E. TARIQ 15

209
CA 21-00220

TODD T. BRIGLIN
    V
NYS DOCCS

CPLR art 78

     TODD T. BRIGLIN SUB
     LAURA ETLINGER SUB

210
CA 21-00924

PLAY

JOSEPH J. TIMPANO
    V
NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE

Declaratory Judgment

  KEITH D. MILLER 10
     TOD M. LASCURETTES SUB
  PAUL G. HANSON 15

211
CA 21-00681

PLAY

ELIZABETH BRITTON
    V
SENECA MEADOWS, INC.

Disqualify Law Firm

  MICHAEL MURPHY 15
     LAURA L. SHEETS SUB

212
CA 21-00064

PLAY

1640 STATE ROUTE 104, LLC
    V
TOWN OF ONTARIO PLANNING BOARD

CPLR art 78

  ROBERT J. MARKS 10
     ANDREW JOHN PINCUS SUB
  ANTHONY J. VILLANI 10

213
CA 21-00253

PLAY

END OF THE HILL, LLC
    V
BROCK ACRES REALTY, LLC

Summary Judgment

  CHAIM JUDAH JAFFE 15
  WARREN B. ROSENBAUM 15

214
CA 21-00451

PLAY

WILLIAM MCGIRR
    V
ROBIN SHIFFLET

Summary Judgment

  JASON M. TELAAK 15
  KEITH N. BOND 15

215
CA 21-00109

PLAY

DEBORAH PIERCE
    V
THOMAS MADEJSKI, M.D.

Summary Judgment

  REBECCA FABIAN IZZO 15
  KATE LORRAINE HARTMAN 15
     PATRICK J. MALONEY 15

215.1
TP 21-01106

ANDREW SEARLES
    V
SHEILA J. POOLE

CPLR art 78 Proceeding Transferred by Order of

     ERIN AMISA TRESMOND SUB
     KATE H. NEPVEU SUB
RULES FILING FORMS ASSIGNED COUNSEL MOTIONS PERFECTING APPEALS ARGUMENTS DECISIONS NOTICES

ACCESSIBILITY

If you are unable to access the archive of a particular argument because of a disability, please contact Alan Ross, Deputy Clerk of the Court and the Court’s designated ADA Liaison (by e-mail at aross@nycourts.gov or by telephone at 585-530-3102), to request a reasonable accommodation.

Hearing Assistance

ASSISTED LISTENING devices are available in each courtroom during arguments. Please see a court attendant when you enter the courtroom.

CLOSED CAPTIONING is available while viewing archived (not live) oral arguments. Hover your mouse over the video and click the [cc] icon to activate the captions. Please note: these captions are generated by a computer algorithm and are not considered a transcript of the proceedings.

Periodically the court may suspend a broadcast to protect the privacy interests of individuals in matters before the Court.

  Comment  Share your thoughts, comments or suggestions as part of the Court's Excellence Initiative.