1. Home
  2. Term
  3. Calendar
August Term

Wed Aug 11 Argument #682

CA 20-01257

ANNMARIE ENGLE
    V
SERGI CONSTRUCTION, INC.

Appeal and cross appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Erie County (Donna M. Siwek, J.), entered August 12, 2020. The order, insofar as appealed from, denied the motion of plaintiffs for summary judgment with respect to serious injury, granted the motion of defendant for summary judgment dismissing the complaint of plaintiff Annmarie Engle and granted in part the motion of defendant for summary judgment against plaintiff Christopher Engle on the issue of serious injury.

Images and video recordings of the Court’s Justices on the Court’s website or otherwise may not be used to advance private interests or in furtherance of any commercial purpose (see Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics Op. 20-158; see generally 22 NYCRR 100.2 [C], 100.4 [D] [3]).

664
KA 18-00921

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
FURQUAN MURRAY

Burglary

  JOHN A. CIRANDO 10
  DARIENN P. BALIN 10

665
KA 19-02350

PEOPLE
    V
HUGH SMITH

Criminal Possession Weapon

     LYLE T. HAJDU SUB
     ASHLEY R. LOWRY SUB

666
KA 17-00689

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
JASON D. HOLLEY

Falsifying Business Records

     JAMES A. HOBBS SUB
  KAYLAN C. PORTER 10

667
KA 18-01895

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
TEWODROS MINWALKULET

Criminal Possession Controlled Substance

  BRIAN SHIFFRIN 10
  V. CHRISTOPHER EAGGLESTON 5

668
KA 19-01368

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
ERIC DEMPSEY

Aggravated Vehicular Homicide

  TYLER B. BUGDEN 15
  KENNETH H. TYLER, JR. 10

669
KA 21-00227

PEOPLE
    V
ANTHONY HICKS

Criminal Possession Weapon

     PAUL GORDON DELL SUB
     MATTHEW B. POWERS SUB

670
KA 20-00747

PEOPLE
    V
HUGH SMITH

Attempted Promoting Prison Contraband

     LYLE T. HAJDU SUB
     ASHLEY R. LOWRY SUB

671
KA 18-00919

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
DALE L. LABELL

Sexual Abuse

  JOHN A. CIRANDO 15
  R. MICHAEL TANTILLO 10

672
KA 19-01175

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
VICTOR VAZQUEZ-MELENDEZ

Criminal Possession Weapon

     WILLIAM G. PIXLEY SUB
  KENNETH H. TYLER, JR. 10

673
KA 19-01176

PLAY

PEOPLE
    V
VICTOR VAZQUEZ-MELENDEZ

Criminal Sale of a Weapon

TO BE ARGUED WITH #672

674
KAH 20-01256

PLAY

PEOPLE EX REL. MARVIN BILLINGER
    V
JOHN HARPER

Habeas Corpus

  NATALIE B. REA 10
  BRIAN D. GINSBERG 10

675
CAF 19-01795

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
SYNCERE D.

Neglect

  DANIELLE K. BLACKABY 10
  ANTHONY PETER BELLETIER, JR. 10
     YVETTE VELASCO SUB
  SUSAN B. MARRIS 10

676
CAF 19-02010

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
JOHN D., JR.

Terminate Parental Rights

TO BE ARGUED WITH #675

677
CAF 19-02013

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
SYNCERE D.

Terminate Parental Rights

TO BE ARGUED WITH #675

678
CAF 19-02014

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
NY'JEEM D.

Terminate Parental Rights

TO BE ARGUED WITH #675

679
CAF 19-02048

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
JOHN D., JR.

Terminate Parental Rights

TO BE ARGUED WITH #675

680
CAF 20-00040

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
SYRE'NITY D.

Neglect

TO BE ARGUED WITH #675

681
OP 20-01405

PLAY

COALITION OF CONCERNED CITIZENS
    V
NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING

Original Proceeding

  GARY A. ABRAHAM 15
  JOHN W. DAX 15
  JOHN C. GRAHAM 15

682
CA 20-01257

PLAY

ANNMARIE ENGLE
    V
SERGI CONSTRUCTION, INC.

Summary Judgment

  JASON M. TELAAK 10
  V. CHRISTOPHER POTENZA 10

683
CA 20-01338

PLAY

STEPHEN T. DIVITO
    V
EDWARD L. FIANDACH

Summary Judgment

  MICHAEL J. WILLETT 15
  DAVID D. BENZ 15

684
CA 20-01029

PLAY

THE CINCINNATI INSURANCE COMPANY
    V
ACADIA INSURANCE COMPANY

Dismiss Complaint

  JARED K. COOK 15
  KATHLEEN A. BARCLAY 10

685
CA 20-01553

PLAY

IN THE MATTER OF
ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY (JAMES M. TWOMEY)

Arbitration

  JUSTIN L. HENDRICKS 15
  RYAN FINN 10

686
OP 20-01406

PLAY

TOWN OF FARMERSVILLE
    V
NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING

Original Proceeding

  BENJAMIN E. WISNIEWSKI 15
  JOHN W. DAX 15
  JOHN C. GRAHAM 15

687
CA 20-01301

PLAY

WILLIAM MATTAR, P.C.
    V
RICHARD HALL, IV

Contract

  RICHARD T. SULLIVAN 15
  JOSEPH A. MATTELIANO 15

688
CA 20-01303

PLAY

WILLIAM MATTAR, P.C.
    V
RICHARD HALL, IV

Contract

TO BE ARGUED WITH #687

689
CA 17-00255

PLAY

MARK SMUKALL
    V
DOLLAR TREE STORES, INC.

Summary Judgment

  BARRY S. ALEXANDER 15
  KELLY RILEY 10
  JAMES J. NASH 15
  V. CHRISTOPHER POTENZA 15

690
CA 20-01686

PLAY

LISA PRIESTER
    V
WILLCARE

Dismiss Complaint

  SARAH RODMAN 15
  MEGHAN M. BROWN 15
  RYAN C. JOHNSEN 15
RULES FILING FORMS ASSIGNED COUNSEL MOTIONS PERFECTING APPEALS ARGUMENTS DECISIONS NOTICES

ACCESSIBILITY

If you are unable to access the archive of a particular argument because of a disability, please contact Alan Ross, Deputy Clerk of the Court and the Court’s designated ADA Liaison (by e-mail at aross@nycourts.gov or by telephone at 585-530-3102), to request a reasonable accommodation.

Hearing Assistance

ASSISTED LISTENING devices are available in each courtroom during arguments. Please see a court attendant when you enter the courtroom.

CLOSED CAPTIONING is available while viewing archived (not live) oral arguments. Hover your mouse over the video and click the [cc] icon to activate the captions. Please note: these captions are generated by a computer algorithm and are not considered a transcript of the proceedings.

Periodically the court may suspend a broadcast to protect the privacy interests of individuals in matters before the Court.

  Comment  Share your thoughts, comments or suggestions as part of the Court's Excellence Initiative.